Originally Posted by Danny-Ray
Amon Amarth are not metal, nor is any of that Norwiegian crap.
I don't understand the logic in that, surely if Reign in Blood is still metal by your definition, then Amon Amarth are still metal.
I could understand if you had said Maiden and Priest were metal but Slayer weren't.
But it seems to me that if a song like Jesus Saves or Epidemic is metal than so is For the Stabwounds in our Backs or Death In Fire.
I understand the need for sub genres, if you are saying Maiden and Priest are metal, and Amon Amarth are melodic death metal, but by the admission that sub genres exist you remove Slayer from metal and place them in Thrash Metal, and the same goes for Rust In Peace.